 |
Third line therapies |
Over the past decade it has become more apparent that many patients with chronic or complex wounds will require treatment with products which are not viewed as 'traditional' wound care products. For a number of years the choice of wound care products available was, to an extent, limited, however, the opposite is true today. With so many products available, how do we categorise them and how do we make informed decisions. It may be useful to classify some of the products into 1st 2nd and 3rd line therapies.
First line treatments could be viewed as those which we apply to wounds which are viewed as healing in a 'normal' fashion. These products include hydrogels, alginates, hydrocolloids, foams and hydrofibres.
Second line therapies are those which also may be used everyday but which may be considered when the wound requires more intense therapy to treat sloughy tissue, malodour, or signs of infection. Products such as antimicrobials in the form of silver, iodine or honey based products and larval therapy may also be included in this list of therapies.
Third line therapies are therefore often used when the more 'routine' treatments are not effective. Our knowledge of wounds has increased greatly over the years and it would appear that many 'third line' therapies have been developed as a result of this new knowledge. Chronic wounds have been shown to exhibit a number of traits which are not present in acute wounds which will prolong the healing process (Sibbald 2000). Often the wound is merely a feature of the patients overall condition, and it has been shown that patients with concurrent illness have many issues which will adversely affect the wound healing environment. Clinically these wounds may appear to be indolent or non healing, or there may be discolouration of the wound bed and/or excessive devitalised tissue present.
Some of the features of a complex and/or chronic wound which may slow or stop healing are listed below:
Features of a chronic/complex wound:
Excessive proteases
Cell senescence
Early cell death or apoptosis
Excessive proteases and reduction of inhibitors.
Excessive exudate
Reduced production of cytokines
Alkalinic pH
Presence of devitalised tissue
Excess bacteria
Prolonged inflammation
Poor vascular supply
Enoch, Grey, and Harding (2006)
Of course it is more important to realise that the patients overall condition will have a huge part to play in the healing of the wound and that dressings are a very small part of the overall equation. What is useful to note, however, that many products available have been developed with these issues in mind. Their mode of action is therefore designed to address some the problems which complex wounds may display. The nature of wound healing dictates that there is no quick fix and therefore the key to any course of treatment is in accurate assessment of the patient and the wound.
Examples of third line products
Promogran (Johnson and Johnson) is a good example of a product which has been developed as a result of improved knowledge of chronic wound healing. Comprising an oxidized collagen matrix Promogran forms a gel in the wound which binds to proteases and acts as a temporary matrix for the cells within the wound. This protects the extracellular matrix materials. Key growth factors are bound to the matrix and released into the wound over time. Vin, Teot and Meume (2002) found an overall greater decrease in leg ulcer size using a combination of Promogran and compression bandaging.
Xelma (Molnlycke)is an extracellular matrix protein (amelogenin) which is combined with an alginate and comes in liquid form for application to chronic wounds. The aim of this product is to improve the cellular environment by forming a temporary matrix for adhesion of cells. In complex wounds the Extracellular Matrix (ECM) can be broken down by excessive proteases. Xelma acting as an ECM can help to support the key cell types in the wound allowing healing to take place. A study of 123 patients with leg ulcers revealed a reduction in overall ulcer size in the Xelma group compared with the control group (using only the alginate component) (Romanelli, Vowden and Ralf et al).
Cadesorb from Smith and Nephew is a pH modulating ointment for use on chronic wounds which may be indolent and/or not responding to treatment. Many chronic wounds have a pH of >7 which indicates an alkalinic wound. Wounds are less likely to heal at this pH, and this is a pH which supports excessive protease activation and reduced inhibition, which in turn leads to breakdown of the ECM (Greener et al 2005). Cadesorb reduces the pH of the wound to around 5.4, which reduces the amount of proteases in the wound, speeding up the healing process.
Vacuum assisted closure or VAC (KCI) has been a major development in the management of chronic or complex wounds. Pioneering work demonstrated that by applying negative pressure, faster tissue growth can be achieved. There are a number of benefits of topical negative pressure (TNP) which include rapid cell division, increase in local blood flow,
reduction in bacteria levels and removal of harmful proteases (Mendez-Eastman 2001).
Conclusion
The above treatments are a small sample of the types of products which are available when faced with hard to heal wounds. Bioengineered skin equivalents are also now more available and have proven useful in treating diabetic foot wounds, however, may not be accessible to all practitioners at this point (Enoch et al 2006). For many of our patients, standard wound healing treatments may be more than adequate, however, there are a number of patients who will not respond to these treatments. It is essential that practitioners are aware of the potential causes of slow or non healing wounds, and as a result know when to utilize products which are designed to improve the
status of such wounds. The number of elderly patients is again set to increase over the next 20 years and it is highly likely that this will be accompanied by an increase in chronic/complex wounds. It is also likely that the third line products of today may become the standard (first line) treatments of tomorrow.
John Timmons
Editor
Enoch, S Grey J E, and Harding KG Recent advances and emerging treatments BMJ, April 22, 2006; 332(7547): 962 - 965.
Greener B et al (2005) Proteases and pH in chronic wounds Journal of Wound Care Vol 14 no. 2
Mendez-Eastman (2001) Guidelines for using negative pressure wound therapy, Advances in skin and wound care vol 14 no. 6 pp314-325
Romanelli M Vowden P and Ralf P et al (2005) the effect of amelogenins on hard to heal venous leg ulcers, precedings EWMA conference Stuttgart
Vin F Teot L and Meume S (2002) The healing properties of Promogran in venous leg ulcers, Journal of Wound Care, Vol 11, no. 9, pp335-341.
 |
Wounds UK Summer Conferences |
Wounds UK held a trio of conferences in Stoneleigh Park, Warwickshire last month. Addressing Paediatric, Dermatology and Generic wound care issues, the conferences were well received and attendance was high. Many companies were also represented in a large exhibition at the event which was extremely popular with the delegates. There were many excellent speakers in all of the conferences and the feedback from the delegates has been very positive.
 |
References |
Adderley, U (2005) Treating malodorous wounds with silver
NURSING IN PRACTICE NUMB 22 pp. 70-74
Blakytny, R.; Jude, E. (2006) The molecular biology of chronic wounds and delayed healing in diabetes
DIABETIC MEDICINE -CHICHESTER- VOL 23; NUMBER 6 pp. 594-608
Lazarides, M. K.; Georgiadis, G. S.; Papas, T. T.; Nikolopoulos, E. S. (2006)
Diagnostic Criteria and Treatment of Buerger's Disease: A Review. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LOWER EXTREMITY WOUNDS
VOL 5; NUMB 2; pp. 89-95
McCrary, B. F. (2006) A Proposed Final Post-Treatment Wound Outcome-Tracking Tool, WOUNDS
VOL 18; NUMB 5; pp. 117-118
Oien, R. F.; Tennvall, G. R. (2006) Accurate diagnosis and effective treatment of leg ulcers reduce prevalence, care time and costs
JOURNAL OF WOUND CARE
VOL 15; NUMB 6 ;pp. 259-268
Pharm, C. T.; Middleton, P. F.; Maddern, G. J. (2006) The safety and efficacy of topical negative pressure in non-healing wounds: a systematic review JOURNAL OF WOUND CARE VOL 15; NUMB 6 pp. 240-253
Seymour, C (2006) Audit of catheter-associated UTI using silver alloy-coated Foley catheters. BRITISH JOURNAL OF NURSING -LONDON- MARK ALLEN PUBLISHING LIMITED-
VOL 15; NUMB 11; pp. 598-603
Silver, S.; Phung, L. T.; Silver, G (2006) Silver as biocides in burn and wound dressings and bacterial resistance to silver compounds
JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL MICROBIOLOGY AND BIOTECHNOLOGY VOL 33; NUMBER 7 (2006) pp. 627-634
Weller, C. (2006) Researching Best Practice Service Provision for People Experiencing Chronic Wounds in the Community in Victoria
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR HUMAN CARING VOL 10; NUMB 2 pp. 65
Yu, H.; Xu, X.; Chen, X.; Hao, J.; Jing, X (2006) Medicated wound dressings based on poly(vinyl alcohol)/poly(N-vinyl pyrrolidone)/chitosan hydrogels
JOURNAL OF APPLIED POLYMER SCIENCE VOL 101; NUMBER 4 pp. 2453-2463
Zoellner, P.; Kapp, H.; Smola, H. (2006) A Prospective, Open-Label Study to Assess the Clinical Performance of a Foam Dressing in the Management of Chronic Wounds
OSTOMY WOUND MANAGEMENT VOL 52; ISSU 5 pp. 34-45
|